Should you buy vitamins from your friends?

The Pediatric Insider

© 2015 Roy Benaroch, MD

Alison wrote in:

 

It seems like every time my (almost 6 year old) child gets sick, a line forms of sales-friends who try to convince me that ‘ever since they gave their child Juice Plus+, they haven’t been sick.’  Could you give your opinion from your medical perspective?  Personally, I prefer to give Flintstones vitamins with the iron, but I’d love to have a better understanding of the best vitamins to give.

 

Vitamins are an interesting psycho-sociological phenomenon. We know that we need them—if you don’t get any vitamin C, you’re fairly quickly going to suffer a fairly horrendous death—but we barely need much of any of them. Just a few milligrams, here and there, not even every day, will keep you and your children chugging along just fine. But, of course, being the creatures that we are, many people seem to view vitamins as having magical abilities. If a tiny bit is good, a whole lot more is better. Or, since some  vitamins are involved in energy metabolism, taking a whole lot of them will give you more energy. Or cure a hangover, or make you invulnerable to colds, the flu, and presidential debates. Magic!

The truth is, vitamins are just chemicals. Like any other chemical, once you swallow it your body doesn’t know or care if it came from a leaf or a pill; and it certainly doesn’t care if it came from a cheapo pill or an expensive, name-brand pill sold by one of your “sales-friends.” A vitamin is a vitamin. If you think your child needs one (and he probably doesn’t), take an inexpensive one and save up some money to buy more yummy fresh fruits and veggies. Because those, he could probably use. A pill that claims to be a replacement for real fruits and real veggies? Sold as part of a multilevel marketing scheme? Please.

What about vitamins for parents? Several good studies in adults show that people who regularly take multivitamins have poorer health. Makes you wonder about all of that vitamin marketing.

Advertisements
Explore posts in the same categories: Nutrition

Tags: ,

You can comment below, or link to this permanent URL from your own site.

3 Comments on “Should you buy vitamins from your friends?”

  1. Frank Camma Says:

    No offense but your remarks regarding vitamins and nutrition reflect your lack of understanding and education despite your medical degree. There is a reason why we fortify our milk with vitamin d and why medical doctors prescribe prenatal vitamins to expectant mothers. The average American diet has no where near the nutrition to support a healthy life. To suggest all foods are just chemicals and similar in composition is not only misinformed but moronic.

    Like

  2. wzrd1 Says:

    I’m in the midst of a very complex relocation. We’re doing the paycheck to paycheck thing while doing so and it’s been protracted beyond six months.
    So, diet is suffering. We chose no megadose multivitamin, but a senior dose multivitamin.
    We supplement *real* foods as we can.
    Oddly, I’m jonesing for a cucumber salad. Might manage to get to that budget this week.

    Like


  3. Im not a doctor … im a mum, and i pretty much have gathered that most isolated vitamins are not what the body recognises!! I know, because we chose to supplement with real food!….granted the fruits and veg are in a capsule, but there is no vitamin label, just a food label.
    basically I put 2 and 2 together, that seen as we are a family of 5, have not seen a doctor, and havent even had a cold in our house for 12 months plus, that this works!! plant based nutrition, there is science to prove bioavailibilty etc…. but i just look at the kids for my proof!!!
    I took out a franchise, and now im able to stay at home with the kids too whilst i work!!
    win / win for me and my repeat customers i have to say with hand on heart!!

    Like


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: