Idiotic attendance policies, part 2: The preschoolers

The Pediatric Insider

© 2012 Roy Benaroch, MD

I’ve written about stupid school policies before—schools that set up carrots and sticks to prevent even genuinely sick kids from staying home. Dumb, dumb, dumb. But it did give me the opportunity to write, “If absences are outlawed, only outlaws will have absences.” I’m not sure exactly what that means, but it seems wise. Someone ought to put it on a bumper sticker.

Now I’m noticing more and more little kids being sent home (and often sent to my office) for equally dumb reasons. I don’t know why, but while the high schools seem to want to keep genuinely sick kids in the classrooms, child care centers for little ones want to send them home for next-to-nothing illnesses. Both extremes aren’t helping keep kids healthy.

The AmericanAcademyof Pediatrics has tried to offer guidance about sensible, science-based pre-school policies to protect the health of children. They’re summarized in this book, also available at Amazon. Owners and operators of preschools and government bodies that make health policies really ought to read that book, and keep it under their pillows at night to help absorb its wisdom. Instead, they seem to be making things up.

School exclusion rules ought to be designed to protect the health of children and staff. Children, in general, ought to stay home if:

  • They can’t comfortably participate
  • Their presence poses a health risk to themselves or others
  • Their presence requires more support than the staff can offer

The AAP has specific suggestions for certain health problems that may surprise you. They certainly run counter to what I’m seeing from day cares in my community. Some of their recommendations:

Kids with the common cold, even if there is green snot, don’t need to be excluded from school. This is because the period of highest infectivity is before symptoms become obvious. Once a child has obvious cold symptoms, they’re no longer very contagious anymore—no matter the color of their snot. As long as they’re comfortable, they can go to school.

Fever, itself, isn’t a reason to keep kids home. Now, most kids with fever are uncomfortable—those kids shouldn’t go to school, since they can’t participate. But some kids with fevers, especially those with viral infections, feel just fine after a dose of ibuprofen. Excluding these children is unlikely to reduce the spread of disease, since most viral infections are spread by children who have no symptoms at all.

Pink eye? This seems to be the biggest boogeyman at preschool. Like the common cold, pink eye is contagious, but there is no evidence that treatment of pink eye reduces the spread of the bacteria or viruses that cause this common infection. The symptoms are quite mild, and will resolve in 5-6 days with or without treatment. The schools freak out, but kids do not go blind from garden-variety pink-eye, and most of them feel fine. As with other illnesses, if the child really feels bad she ought to stay home. Note that there are rare, more-serious occasional outbreaks of more-serious pink eye caused by adenovirus, so a classroom with multiple cases of severe pink eye needs to be reported to public health authorities. But the vast majority of pink eye that’s referred “emergently” to my office are very mild, nearly symptom-free infections.

Infections that really ought to stay home are those that include diarrhea that can’t be contained in a diaper or requires frequent changes, or vomiting. These symptoms really can’t be managed safely or comfortably in a group care setting.

Wrongheaded day care policies probably drive a lot of my business. Many centers seem to require a “note from a doctor” to return to school. Still, wrong is wrong. What we need is a more sensible approach to group care and school illnesses, rather than knee-jerk policies that keep children and parents home or send them to my office. Sick kids ought to stay home, but most kids with mild illnesses who feel pretty well can go to school safely.

Explore posts in the same categories: Medical problems

Tags: , , , , ,

You can comment below, or link to this permanent URL from your own site.

7 Comments on “Idiotic attendance policies, part 2: The preschoolers”

  1. sheri flink Says:

    I forwarded this blog entry to my child’s preschool. You must have been reading my mind today!!


  2. Dr. Roy Says:

    Sheri, hope it helps! I probably should have chosen a nicer title tho…


  3. Rachel T. Says:

    Don’t even get me started on “no-nit” lice policies.


  4. Dr. Roy Says:

    Rachel’s exactly right– “no nit” policies are not recommended by any legit health authority, yet they are somehow pervasive in schools. More about lice:


  5. Debra Says:

    I have to agree with you and the idea of sending this article to the school nurse sounds good as well. Thanks for the tip.


  6. Fizzy Says:

    I love this entry. My baby has been sent home three times this year with “conjunctivitis.” Her conjunctiva weren’t even red, just some crust in the corner. She wasn’t allowed back in until the pediatrician gave her antibiotic drops.

    I don’t know if you realize this, but many moms put these leftover antibiotic drops in their kids’ eyes when they notice any goop to prevent the kid from being sent home. It’s insane.


  7. There’s a super easy explanation for all of the nonsense: Money.

    Day care/Pre-School gets paid whether your child is there or not. If enough children are out sick, they can send a teacher home, therefore lowering their costs while maintaining their revenues. Therefore, they are motivated to send sick children home.

    Public schools, however, are funded based on attendance. If your kid is not there for one day, the school loses one day worth of funding. It’s a ridiculous system. However, they want the students there as much as possible because they get the most funding that way.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: